2stroker wrote:
I hear this a lot and always wonder where the idea that foam style filters are no good off road came from.
They are great off road, in an appropriate application (in free air) appropriately maintained (after each dusty drive) and for an appropriate engine (where rebuilds are frequent,and space is very limited- like dirt bikes)
In short, foam is for competition use where there's inadequate room for anything more complex, and maintenance isn't an issue.
Quote:
I do agree that the Suzuki factory airbox is good as it is and doesn't really need improvement unless you need to increase airflow due to fitting a larger capacity engine.
The factory suzuzki air box is rubbish. It was built to a price (like the rest of the car) and does not seal or filter well enough for Australian conditions. The element itself is well sized (in a 1.3) but the cheap construction of the box means it rarely seals very well. It's really just the plastic flexing and the clips being inadequate.
Quote:
Heavy earth moving and mining equipment also use oil air filter systems because of the dusty conditions.
Please show me some evidence of these systems. I am unaware of them. Do you actually mean an oiled foam primary element? This is very surprising. If you mean an oil bath air cleaner, that's a different device entirely and isn't well suited to the angles an off road car sees, although they are very efficient as a filter.
Foam filters are a complete PITA in a stock air box, mostly because the air box can no longer operate properly. All the debris that enters the air box ends up stuck to the filter. With a paper filter, only a small percentage of the dirt that enters the air box ends up on the filter - the coarse stuff falls off the filter and ends up in the bottom of the box. With an oiled foam filter, service intervals go up because that doesn't happen any more. This is the #1 problem with oiled foam filters in OEM applications.
Just because something works on a 2 stroke or a motor that's rebuilt yearly (or less) doesn't mean it's appropriate for our use.
I have used Crap&N and uni filters in and out of air boxes. My car runs paper in a Hi-ace air box. If that is inadequate (it isn't currently) I'll run a donaldson pre-cleaner, or upgrade to a larger cyclopac-style air box.
Foam or oiled gauze won't go anywhere near an off road car for my use.
Steve.